Fractures in nuclear graphite

Collaboration with EDF Energy and Jacobs/Amentum

UK Nuclear Power Plant Safety

The team that founded Mesh-Oriented Solutions worked together successfully on developing MoFEM to meet the needs of the UK nuclear industry—EDF Energy and Jacobs/Amentum. The work focused on providing simulation capabilities to predict fracture in the cores of UK nuclear power plants. MoFEM delivered an advanced crack propagation simulation tool that predicted fractures far more accurately than any commercial or open-source code. EDF Energy commissioned two independent audits of MoFEM, in 2017 and 2019. Based on these, MoFEM was approved for use in safety cases supporting the continued operation of UK nuclear power plants. Since then, MoFEM has been used consistently by engineers at EDF Energy and Jacobs/Amentum. The work resulted in:

  • Impact on Nuclear Safety: Facilitating the use of novel technology for simulations supporting safety cases for the UK’s nuclear power plants operations, thanks to sustainable development practices within the MoFEM team.

  • REF2021 Impact Case Submission: Submitting an impact case to REF2021, demonstrating significant cross-disciplinary applications of the research.

The simulated crack paths coincide very well with observed fractures in nuclear graphite
Formation of debris: comparison between the experiment and MoFEM simulation (Athanasiadis et al., 2023)

Configurational Mechanics in Heterogeneous Materials

Accuracy and robustness of crack propagation in nuclear graphite were achieved by implementing a novel computational framework in MoFEM,
“Configurational Mechanics for Modelling Continuous Crack Propagation in Heterogeneous Materials” which extends the principles of configurational mechanics to modelling crack propagation in brittle, heterogeneous materials. Key aspects of this work include:

  • Theoretical Basis: Utilizing principles of configurational mechanics, based on the local form of the first law of thermodynamics, for establishing equilibrium conditions for the crack front.

  • Crack Propagation Direction: Applying the principle of maximal energy dissipation to determine the direction of crack propagation in line with configurational forces.

  • Handling Heterogeneous Materials: Extending previous formulations to include the influence of spatially varying material stiffness, introducing an additional force influencing the crack front movement.

  • Monolithic Solution Strategy: Simultaneously solving for material and spatial displacements, enabling discrete displacement discontinuity resolution without the need for mesh refinement or enrichment techniques.

  • Advanced Numerical Techniques: Implementing arc-length procedures for dissipative loading path tracing and mesh smoothing for maintaining mesh quality.

  • Demonstration of Efficacy: Validating the performance of this formulation through numerous numerical simulations, showcasing both accuracy and robustness.

This research marks a significant contribution to both the fields of engineering mechanics and nuclear safety, demonstrating the versatility and impact of the methodologies developed in MoFEM.

Primary crack propagation in nuclear graphite brick (MoFEM simulation)
Secondary crack propagation in graphite brick (MoFEM simulation)

References

2023

  1. CMAME
    A computational framework for crack propagation along contact interfaces and surfaces under load
    Ignatios Athanasiadis, Andrei G Shvarts, Zahur Ullah, and 3 more authors
    Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 2023